How to Choose a Centers of Excellence Program Provider

Key Takeaways
A Centers of Excellence (COE) program directs employees to vetted clinicians and facilities for complex, high-cost care, often at a single bundled price.
The four provider models are carrier-based, facility-based, independent networks, and integrated platforms, and clinician-level quality data should drive the choice.
Employers need to validate savings against their own claims, and utilization depends on reaching employees when surgery first comes up.
Private health insurance spending grew 8.8% in 2024 and a projected 8.2% in 2025, per the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services. Employers are responding with Centers of Excellence (COE). In a Business Group on Health survey, 84% of large employers plan to offer at least one COE in 2027.
Deciding to offer a COE is the easy part. Choosing the right provider is harder, and a uninformed choice can lead to low use and unverified savings. This guide covers provider models, evaluation criteria, and vendor questions to help employers with this choice.
What Is a Centers of Excellence Program?
A Centers of Excellence program is an employer benefit that directs employees to pre-vetted clinicians and facilities for complex, high-cost care. In one employer bundled-payment program, selected clinicians received one price for spinal fusion, joint replacement, or bariatric surgery plus related care. Employees paid nothing out of pocket. That example reflects the four building blocks most programs share:
Curated network: Clinicians and facilities chosen on outcomes, volume, and appropriateness.
Bundled payment: One fixed price for a full episode of care.
Employee support: Care coordination, travel help, and pre-surgery review.
Incentives: Reduced or waived cost-sharing to encourage use.
Types of Centers of Excellence Program Providers
Employers take various approaches to Centers of Excellence. For buying purposes, providers tend to fit four models.
Carrier-based: Built into a health plan, easy to launch, limited customization.
Facility-based: Brand-name health systems, often requiring travel.
Independent networks: Surgeon-level vetting through a separate centers-of-excellence vendor.
Integrated platforms: COE care inside navigation, second opinions, and primary care.
How Centers of Excellence Programs Have Evolved
Traditional programs, typically offered through a carrier or a single facility, focused on discounted prices at a few designated sites. Modern programs, offered independently or integrated with broader navigation, focus on whether care is needed, who delivers it, and how easily employees can use it. Here’s how they compare:
Feature | Traditional COE | Modern COE |
Clinician selection | Facility designation | Clinician-level outcomes data |
Access | Few sites, often far away | Broad network closer to home |
Appropriateness review | Often optional | Clinical review or expert opinion |
Pricing | Fee-for-service or discounts | Bundled, transparent pricing |
Employee engagement | Open-enrollment outreach | Guidance at the moment of need |
How to Evaluate a Centers of Excellence Program Provider
Not every provider delivers the same results, so the evaluation should go beyond price. Five factors separate strong programs from the rest:
Surgical volume and outcomes: Experience with a procedure shapes results. A JAMA Surgery study of Medicare complex elective surgery found 8.1% 30-day mortality at low-volume hospitals versus 5.5% at hospitals meeting volume standards.
Appropriateness review: Clinical review confirms surgery is right before scheduling.
Network access: Enough high-quality sites to serve employees where they live, with travel support when the best option may be farther away.
Validated pricing: Savings are rebuilt from the employer's own claims rather than a vendor benchmark.
Point-of-need engagement: The program reaches employees when surgery comes up.
In JAMA Health Forum studies, Medicare joint replacement bundles were tied to lower episode spending. A Medicare Advantage bundle lowered spending with no change in quality. Employer evidence is thinner.
Questions to Ask a Centers of Excellence Vendor
Benefits leaders should ask each Centers of Excellence vendor how it selects clinicians, prices care, and proves results. Use these questions in vendor reviews or requests for proposal (RFPs), and ask for data, not just descriptions.
How are clinicians and facilities selected and re-reviewed? Look for outcomes data at the clinician level and regular re-review, not a one-time designation.
Is every surgery reviewed for appropriateness, with an expert opinion option? Look for review before scheduling, not after.
How well does the network cover our workforce? Look for high-quality sites near where employees live, plus travel support when the best option is farther away.
Are prices bundled, with capped fees or performance guarantees? Look for one price per episode that includes follow-up care.
Do you cover the cost of complications or readmissions? Look for a warranty or guarantee, which signals confidence in quality.
Will savings be validated against our own claims? Look for a claims comparison, not industry benchmarks.
What share of eligible employees use the program? Look for utilization data from similar employers and a plan to reach people when surgery is first recommended.
How does the program connect to navigation and primary care? Look for referrals that flow in automatically rather than relying on employees to remember the benefit.
These answers matter most when the program sits inside a broader health and care experience. Connecting the program to navigation, primary care, and expert second opinions helps employees find it when surgery is first discussed, driving both use and savings.
How Transcarent Approaches Centers of Excellence Programs
Transcarent connects Members to its Centers of Excellence network as part of a broader health and care experience, guiding them toward the right surgical path from the first question. The WayFinding® platform is the first practical use of agentic artificial intelligence (AI) and human support across benefits navigation, clinical guidance, and care delivery. Agentic AI takes action on a Member's behalf, like scheduling care and following up.
Surgery Care works alongside the employer's existing health plan, adding expert clinical review, 2nd.MD expert medical opinions, and nurse-led care coordination. It spans more than 2,900 contracted Centers of Excellence and specialty care sites nationwide, with bundled pricing. Clients see average savings of $17,943 per surgical episode.
Results are based on internal program data; individual outcomes may vary.
Choosing the Right Centers of Excellence Program
Start your evaluation with the questions above, and ask every provider for data rather than promises. The right partner will show clinician outcomes, review surgery for appropriateness, and validate savings against your own claims. Benefits leaders can explore how Surgery Care and the WayFinding platform bring these together.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the purpose of a Center of Excellence?
Centers of Excellence aims to concentrate complex care with clinicians and facilities that perform a procedure often. For employers, the goal is a clear, priced path for their most expensive care.
What types of Centers of Excellence program providers exist?
Buyers commonly group them into four models: carrier-based, facility-based, independent networks, and integrated platforms. The right fit depends on how much customization and connection to other benefits an employer wants.
How are Centers of Excellence programs paid for?
The self-insured employer's plan typically pays one bundled price per episode of care. Contracts that cap vendor fees or tie them to performance guarantees make total cost easier to forecast.
How can employers verify Centers of Excellence savings?
An actuary or benefits consultant can compare actual episode costs with the employer's historical claims for the same procedures. Contracts should also grant audit rights to the underlying claims data.
Should employers make Centers of Excellence participation required?
Requiring use can raise volume, but it may frustrate employees who live far from a site. Incentives such as waived deductibles offer a softer start.
References
Business Group on Health. (2025, August). 2026 employer health care strategy survey: Executive summary. Business Group on Health.
Business Group on Health. (2026, August 25). Cost volatility forces employers to reassess healthcare strategy, Business Group on Health survey reveals. Business Group on Health.
Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services, Office of the Actuary. (2026). National health expenditure projections 2025–2034: Forecast summary. Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services.
Crowley, A. P., Kilaru, A. S., Huang, Q. E., Wang, E., Zhu, J., Arora, A., Shirk, T., Cousins, D. S., Linn, K. A., Ibrahim, S. A., Liao, J. M., & Navathe, A. S. (2025). Physician and hospital performance in Medicare's updated bundled-payment model for joint replacement. JAMA Health Forum, 6(7), e251930.
Kalata, S., Schaefer, S. L., Nuliyahu, U., Ibrahim, A. M., & Nathan, H. (2024). Low-volume elective surgery and outcomes in Medicare beneficiaries treated at hospital networks. JAMA Surgery, 159(2), 203–210.
Sutherland, A., Boudreau, E., Bowe, A., Huang, Q., Liao, J. M., Flagg, M., Cousins, D., Antol, D. D., Shrank, W. H., Powers, B. W., & Navathe, A. S. (2023). Association between a bundled payment program for lower extremity joint replacement and patient outcomes among Medicare Advantage beneficiaries. JAMA Health Forum, 4(6), e231495.
Whaley, C. M., Dankert, C., Richards, M., & Bravata, D. (2021). An employer-provider direct payment program is associated with lower episode costs. Health Affairs, 40(3), 445–452.
